Many homeowners wonder if a home warranty is worth buying when they already have homeowners insurance. The answer depends on what kind of protection you’re looking for.
Homeowners Insurance: Protection Against Disasters
Homeowners insurance is designed for emergencies. It typically covers:
Structural damage (from fires, hurricanes, etc.)
Personal property (like furniture and electronics)
Liability (in case someone gets injured on your property)
It does not cover repairs due to wear and tear.
Home Warranty: Coverage for Everyday Breakdowns
A home warranty fills in the gaps that insurance doesn’t cover. It helps pay for repairs or replacements of:
HVAC systems
Electrical and plumbing
Water heaters
Major appliances like stoves, washers, and dryers
These items wear down over time—and that’s where a home warranty becomes valuable.
When Both Are Beneficial
Consider the following:
Your insurance kicks in after disasters.
Your warranty kicks in when your 10-year-old air conditioner suddenly dies.
Owning both means you’re protected whether your home is damaged in a storm or your refrigerator stops cooling unexpectedly.
Cost Considerations
Insurance Premium: $1,000–$2,000/year (average)
Home Warranty: $300–$800/year, plus service fees ($75–$125 per claim)
The cost of a single appliance or HVAC repair can easily exceed the price of a yearly warranty.
Conclusion
Homeowners insurance is essential; a home warranty is optional but often worthwhile. If you want full protection, especially for older systems, having both may offer the peace of mind you need.